Monday 3 August 2020

Pandora's Box and Hope: A Blessing or Curse?

I am a massive nerd for anything historical, but Ancient History and mythology is how a lot of people get into the subject and I really do not blame them; is there any myth that isn’t great? Well, there are probably some, but one that certainly is not is Pandora’s Box. When you are young it is really just a myth about a smoking hot lady, Pandora, who might have done well in the looks department, but not so much in the smarts department; she ends up stumbling across a box that she just has to open, releasing all the evils into the world, leaving only one thing inside: hope. It is kind of hard to believe this all happened so long ago, when so much has happened in 2020 – are we sure they weren’t simply predicting the future?

When I was a child and I read this, I too just believed this to be an interesting myth with an optimistic message at the end. Now, as an adult, I realise how naïve I was (and the rest of this post will show how we should cling on to our naivety a little longer). We could always talk about the beautiful woman without brains who brought evil to the world, because there is a lot to unpack there, but I would rather look at the one thing left in the box.

We are told that hope is left in the box, so humans always have it, despite all the evils left in the world. That is what is in the mythology story books, and that is what most people will recall from the myth, and it is a pleasantly optimistic view. Still, it dawned on me, as it has some scholars, that if hope is in the box, do we have hope? This came on me at a random time because I have found myself with time where I can think about these big questions for absolutely no good reason, and my friends usually get the brunt of my waffling – but now I have this, so you can read it too, out of choice!

Griffith suggests that the myth of Pandora’s Box is not as optimistic as we are taught as children, but that hope is actually a blessing withheld from us, to make our suffering just that much worse. People only began to suffer from evil when Pandora opens the box and releases it into the world, so if hope is left in the box, how would humans have access to it? The reason Pandora was created was to have her open the box and release these evils upon the human race, so might it have been part of the plan to have it slammed shut just before hope got out?

It is a fair interpretation, but there is another possible reason hope was in the box: is hope a bad thing? The original text for the myth has been translated several times, and some have come to the conclusion that the word is ‘hope’, while others have suggested it should be translated rather as ‘deceptive expectation’. Everything in the box was to cause suffering for humanity, and is there anything worse than expecting better only to find out that it will only ever remain an expectation? Is having hope actually causing us more pain than the other evils in the world?

Still, I think we should remain optimistic. Earlier I said we should remain naïve, but it is not naïve to believe that hope is a good thing, or to be optimistic. Without hope, even ‘deceptive expectation’, nothing would be achieved; hope pushes us forward, allowing us to create change ourselves. ‘Deceptive expectation’ is to only believe that someone else will come along and solve our problems and cure us of the evil in the world. Once you create your own path and your actions influence the bettering of the world, even if it is just your world, hope is a blessing.


Pandora's Box and Hope: A Blessing or Curse?

I am a massive nerd for anything historical, but Ancient History and mythology is how a lot of people get into the subject and I really do n...